Tim Burton's Sleepy Hollow, loosely based on Washington Irving's classic story, is neither sleepy nor hollow, but it isn't the most exciting movie to come out during the Thanksgiving season either.
The film is set in 1799 where the little town of Sleepy Hollow has been plagued the presence of a headless horseman who goes out decapitating heads. There is a pattern to his madness and it is up to Ichabod Crane (Johnny Depp), a would-be detective with a mindset firmly rooted in analytical methods, to discover it. At first, Crane scoffs at the possibility of the supernatural causing the deaths, but as he becomes entangled in a web of intrigue and mysticism involving the Van Tassel and Van Brunt families, he realises the sinister nature of the beheadings.
The plot finally leads to a confrontation between the pitiful Headless Horseman, a former Hessian soldier who was beheaded but now summoned by witchcraft for nefarious purposes, and Crane and it is a bit too conventional. The chemistry/tension between Crane and Katrina Van Tassel (Christina Ricci) is close to absent and in general there is very little character development, though the actors (especially the supporting cast) present fine performances.
The cinematography, set design, and special effects, in my mind, is what makes Sleepy Hollow worthwhile to watch. It is bleak, dark, and very typical of Tim Burton's previous work, and it is excellently done. There are some scary moments and there is enough gore to frighten and disgust. The pacing is decent enough to keep you awake. The strength of the supporting cast leads to an extremely convincing setting for the film, where the moody atmosphere reaches out from the screen and takes a hold of you. Ultimately Sleepy Hollow is a fairly conventional horror movie which looks extremely good and sounds even better, thanks to a great score by Danny Elfman.
I have to say that I watched Sleepy Hollow when I was in an extremely distracted frame of mind, but yet it held my attention enough to follow it. At a minimum, I think that makes a movie worth watching. However, I'd wait for this one to come out on video.